24 Comments

Oh, Team Butter, 100%!

Expand full comment

Butter really does taste better!

Expand full comment

I once had an assignment to write a case study about a margarine factory. It was one of the grossest experiences. I will spare the margarine eaters the details but my advice is stick with butter.

Expand full comment

Your reasoning is compelling! I'm morbidly curious to learn the inner workings of a margarine factory, though.

Expand full comment

Chiming in a bit late to the comment party here. Both of your memories are pretty accurate about our butter use while raising a family. Fun fact: we joined the corn oil margarine train after grandpa's first open-heart surgery in 1974, the year Erin was born, because (as was mentioned) the medical wisdom of the day said it was more heart healthy. Over the years, probably since the mid 1980s, we've come back to team butter, including the spreadable tub variety with olive oil and always sticks of butter for baking. I attribute your Dad's quadruple bypass surgery nearly 8 years ago more to genetics than to what he spreads on his toast.

I really enjoyed reading this post, Erin, and I appreciate how you include historical facts and photos to engage your readers. Margarine seems to provide evidence that necessity is truly the Mother of invention, but it might be a challenge to find hardened whale oil to make our own today!

Expand full comment

Thanks for chiming in, Mom! Really interesting to get the backstory on my recollection of a margarine-favoring childhood. Grandpa strictly followed that "heart healthy" diet-- I remember being disappointed when we were served "ice milk" instead of ice cream at Grandpa & Grandma's house.

Expand full comment

At Aldi this week the butter was cheaper than margarine.

Expand full comment

What sorcery is that?!

Expand full comment

My vegetarian wasteland years from 1989-2009 gave me more than my fill of "fake food". I'll stick with butter until the bitter, bitter end. I'll cut back on cheese, yogurt, and the "nice" toilet paper before I give up my butter.

Expand full comment

I admire your solid stand and willingness to sacrifice for butter. My vegetarian years were 1991-2003-- I agree there were some pretty gnarly fake foods during those years. One of the worst may have been soy cheese-- creepy how it didn't melt ever.

Expand full comment

I am confused! Butter with canola oil in plastic container doesn’t count as butter?

Also, we were not a family who used butter when we lived in Wisconsin! ( kids approx. 4 &1/2,3 ,and 1 & 1/2)! Oleo was cheaper but it was white! We had to mix it with a substance to make it yellow. I think Wisconsin is a dairy state!

Expand full comment

That's really interesting, Grandma! So you did buy oleo when you were a young married couple on a tight budget in the '50's (even though you lived in the dairy state). So strange that you had to add the coloring yourself! I also read that some margarine was pink?!

The thing with canola oil is that it's not supposed to be as healthy as olive oil...

Expand full comment

We buy Amish butter, with our local hardware store as the go-between. I have a condition that makes me super-sensitive to fakey foodstuff, so I can’t do margarine.

Expand full comment

It's great that you have farm-fresh butter locally available! Food sensitivities are no fun.

Expand full comment

Always butter for baking. My other half grew up similar to us…butter at grandmas and margarine at home. Since getting married I think I interchangeably buy spreadable butter and tubs of margarine depending on the deals at the store or what sounds good. As a result we are pretty balanced over here. We like both!!! When it comes to cutting costs I can definitely hang in the margarine club for as long as needed. Fun read. Especially loved the graphics.

Expand full comment

Thanks for reading and chiming in!

Expand full comment

Butter reigns! But I need a specific margarine in my house due to food allergies. Plus, I use margarine in some cookies so they don't spread so much.

Expand full comment

You bought margarine back in the day though right? Cost cutter plus diet food etc?!? I will say that I have an earlier memory of butter entering my house growing up than my sister but it probably has to do with our age gap. We had butter for toast, etc. but probably only if we were not in a penny pinching month.

Expand full comment

You're likely right, sis-- my memories of mom's food stores wouldn't be so clear from the years after I moved out.

Expand full comment

You bring up 2 great points there. Having a readily available butter substitute is necessary for food allergies. And I've had to alter the butter measurements in baking recipes that call for margarine.

Expand full comment

Those delicious croutons were made with olive oil and......butter 🧈.

Expand full comment

Noooooo!! 😫

Expand full comment

Isn’t that technically baking?

Expand full comment

LOL, he could make that case!

Expand full comment